LSAT Question Stem
The reasoning in the argument is most subject to criticism on the grounds that the argument
Logical Reasoning Question Type
This is a Flaw question.
Correct Answer
The correct answer to this question is C.
LSAT Question Complete Explanation
The question type for this problem is a Flaw question, which asks us to identify the flaw in the argument's reasoning.
Let's first break down the argument and label each part as either a premise or a conclusion:
1. Premise: According to some astronomers, Earth is struck by a meteorite large enough to cause an ice age on an average of once every 100 million years.
2. Premise: The last such incident occurred nearly 100 million years ago.
3. Sub-conclusion: So, we can expect that Earth will be struck by such a meteorite in the near future.
4. Main Conclusion: This clearly warrants funding to determine whether there is a means to protect our planet from such meteorite strikes.
The problem with this argument is that it uses an average frequency of an event (meteorite strikes) to make a specific prediction about when the next event will occur. To illustrate this flaw, imagine a person who flips a coin and gets heads five times in a row. Just because the average outcome is 50% heads and 50% tails, it doesn't mean that the next flip will definitely be tails. The past flips do not affect the probability of future flips.
Now, let's evaluate the answer choices:
a) This answer choice is incorrect because the argument does not establish a high probability for a disastrous event. It only provides information about the average frequency of meteorite strikes.
b) This answer choice is also incorrect because the argument actually assumes that the probability of a meteorite strike is affected by the time since the last strike, not that it is unaffected.
c) This answer choice is correct because it identifies the flaw in the argument: moving from evidence about the average frequency of an event to a specific prediction about when the next such event will occur.
d) This answer choice is incorrect because the likelihood of a meteorite causing an ice age is not the main flaw in the argument. Even if the likelihood is low, there could be other consequences of a meteorite strike that warrant funding for protection measures.
e) This answer choice is incorrect because the argument does not presume that a feasible means to deter large meteorite strikes can be found. It only suggests that we should investigate the possibility of protecting Earth from such strikes.
